Menu of Reedy Creek Steakhouse in Screven, Georgia, USA

Menu Overview

Reedy Creek Steakhouse, nestled at 1633 Clifford Jones Rd in Screven, Georgia, is an embodiment of rustic charm fused with culinary excellence. This steakhouse offers more than just hearty cuts of meat; it creates an inviting haven where every detail—from the atmosphere to the food—is crafted with care.

The menu is a thoughtful journey through classic Southern comfort with refined touches. Start your meal with the homemade bread paired with their signature pimento cheese spread—a creamy, tangy delight that sets the tone for what’s to come. The salad bar is both fresh and unique, boasting a mix of crisp greens and inventive sides that cater to diverse palates. Reviewers consistently praise the cracker salad, a standout that balances texture and flavor perfectly.

When it comes to main courses, Reedy Creek Steakhouse excels at delivering perfectly cooked steaks, as confirmed by patrons who experienced filet mignon and ribeye cooked to exact specifications. The “Surf Turf and Air” offers a clever contrast of land and sea, with succulent shrimp alongside savory steak, complemented by sweet potato fries that add a subtle sweetness to the palate. Seafood lovers find satisfaction in the flawlessly cooked salmon, which brings a tender, flaky texture while maintaining its natural flavors.

The children’s menu is thoughtfully curated as well, featuring the Kids Steak and Chicken Tenders—both comforting and well-executed dishes that can please the youngest guests. This attention to family-friendly options broadens the steakhouse’s appeal beyond the traditional steak lover.

Endings at Reedy Creek call for the Banana Pudding and classic Cheesecake, desserts that feel like a warm nod to Southern roots. The banana pudding, interestingly made without bananas, surprises with its richness and creamy consistency, while the cheesecake remains light yet indulgent.

Beyond the food, the setting amplifies the dining experience. Housed in a charming old building overlooking a peaceful pond and cow field, the ambiance is calm and inviting. The presence of “Tiger,” the friendly local cat, adds a whimsical, homey touch that makes visitors feel genuinely welcomed.

Service here matches the food’s quality—attentive, courteous, and genuine. Whether dining in a small group or with a large party, guests enjoy prompt service that never feels rushed. While the absence of alcohol might surprise some, it aligns with the local culture and does not detract from the overall experience.

Reedy Creek Steakhouse stands as a testament to Southern hospitality and culinary tradition. It’s a place where simplicity meets excellence, and where each dish tells a story of craftsmanship and care. For those seeking an authentic steakhouse experience rich in flavor and comfort, this is a destination well worth the visit.